NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on the High 2021 Authorized Developments Affecting NY’s CRE Trade: Olshan Actual Property Legislation Weblog

NYREJ Publishes Article by Thomas Kearns on the High 2021 Authorized Developments Affecting NY’s CRE Trade

New York Actual Estate Journal revealed an article on January 25 authored by Olshan Actual Property companion Thomas Kearns entitled “High 2021 Authorized Developments Affecting New York’s Business Actual Property Trade.”

My 12 months finish article final 12 months began with: “2020 might be remembered for COVID-19 and extra COVID-19.” 2021 has most positively not been a return to regular and the pandemic continues to affect the trade however courts returned to motion and legislatures continued to deal with the pandemic.

Listed below are a number of gadgets that will have lasting affect:

Moratorium on Sure Evictions and Foreclosures; Tenants Should Pay Lease 

New York State’s restrictions on sure evictions and foreclosures which have been initially applied by Government Orders in 2020 have been adopted into regulation by statue in 2021 and later prolonged till January 15, 2022. The restrictions apply to residential tenants and debtors and sure industrial tenants and debtors with 100 or fewer workers who, in every case, have suffered a hardship as a result of COVID-19 pandemic. The state has additionally created funding to help residential tenants in paying hire. Notably the regulation doesn’t absolve the tenant or borrower from paying the hire or mortgage funds due (however see beneath for a dialogue of a separate metropolis regulation absolving sure guarantors from obligations). In a separate appellate ruling in The Hole, Inc., v. 170 Broadway Retail Proprietor, LLC, New York’s Appellate Division, First Division, overturned one of many few trial court docket rulings in favor of a industrial tenant as to the claims that the pandemic triggered the lease’s casualty clause or in any other case entitled the tenant to hire abatements below the widespread regulation doctrines of frustration of function or impossibility. Briefly, New York appellate courts have reaffirmed longstanding regulation that except there’s an categorical lease provision granting a particular hire abatement, industrial tenants should pay hire.

New York Metropolis Legislation Vitiating Ensures Questioned 

Whereas upheld by a number of state and federal trial courts, the Second Circuit Court docket of Appeals in Melendez v. Metropolis of New York raised a number of constitutional points as as to whether the regulation could be enforced. Town regulation forbids the enforcement of lease ensures the place sure meals and non-essential retail shops have been closed throughout the pandemic by Government Orders. The Circuit Court docket despatched the case again to the trial court docket for additional consideration which was nonetheless pending on the time this column is being written.

Money Out Mergers in LLCs 

Money out mergers are a potent weapon within the fingers of the bulk in curiosity in an LLC to merge out the minority. Nearly all of members can vote to merge into a brand new entity which the bulk or others management at a worth that they decide of their judgment. A 2021 appellate ruling in Farro v. Schochet upheld a money out merger towards a declare of fraud and held that the minority has one and just one treatment – an LLC regulation part 1002(f) judicial appraisal continuing. For a New York LLC, except the LLC settlement is on the contrary, the bulk members can merge into a brand new entity and the minority members’ sole treatment is to dissent to the merger and search the appraisal rights. The appraisal treatment does give minority members safety since they’re entitled to a judicial analysis of the equity of the merger consideration however the appellate ruling does take away a leverage level—the events will battle out the worth in court docket however the merger itself will go ahead with out an injunction by the court docket.

Reactions to Rental Collapse 

The summer time’s collapse of the condominium in Surfside, Florida and the observe up investigative journalism revealed weaknesses within the typical apartment administration construction—apartment board members who pushed to finish pricey structural repairs have been voted out and the apartment paperwork had too powerful voting necessities for giant initiatives. Into the combo got here Fannie Mae, the federal company that gives a lot of the liquidity to the residential mortgage market. Fannie has toughened its necessities for loans it should purchase by including extra opinions of reserves and pending structural repairs. Additionally added by Fannie was a reminder to appraisers to doc deferred upkeep on the constructing. Anticipate extra on this space.

Zoning and Constructing Approvals 

A number of neighborhood re-zonings and particular person constructing approvals made their method by means of metropolis approval processes this 12 months together with the SoHo/NoHo and Gowanus neighborhood re-zonings, and approvals for the New York Blood Heart on East 67th St. in Manhattan and the Howard Hughes Corp.’s deliberate constructing on the South Road Seaport. I gained’t touch upon who gained or misplaced in these battles because the forwards and backwards and posturing are too onerous for a mere mortal to parse, however the legislative and administrative actions give attention to how New York should steadiness maintaining with altering neighborhoods with preserving its neighborhoods and landmarks whereas on the identical time growing density and the provision of housing, significantly inexpensive housing.

Thomas Kearns is a companion with  Olshan Frome Wolosky LLP’s actual property division, New York, N.Y.

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles